A rock, a keeper's house and a lighthouse that has to read as one at three pixels wide.
Click either picture to zoom in.
The first world on this site, and still the one I redraw most. The rule I set myself was simple: the lighthouse is three pixels wide and it still has to look like a lighthouse. Red and white stripes every two rows did most of the work; the gallery rail is one dark row that sticks out a pixel on each side.
The night version is the same drawing. The lamp, the house window and the glint on the water are “sleeping” colours: by day they match whatever is next to them, at night they switch on. That trick ended up shaping every world after this one.
The beam is two frames, left and right, and it's checker-dithered so it reads as light rather than paint. It thins out with distance, which is about as much physics as 48 pixels can hold.
What I'd change
The island is too symmetrical. Next time it gets a jetty, and maybe a boat that only shows up in the day version.